Which account do you draw from first?
Retirement savings usually sit in three kinds of accounts, taxed three different ways. The order you draw from them shapes lifetime tax, how much Old Age Security you keep, and what a survivor inherits.
Retirement savings usually sit in three kinds of accounts, taxed three different ways. The order you draw from them shapes lifetime tax, how much Old Age Security you keep, and what a survivor inherits.
Here is the short version. Money out of an RRSP or a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) is fully taxable as income. TFSA withdrawals are tax-free and don't count as income for Old Age Security (OAS) or the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS). A non-registered account is taxed along the way, on interest, dividends and realized capital gains. There is no single correct order. In practice it is a decision made again every year, not once at the retirement party.
Three accounts, three tax treatments
RRSP and RRIF. Every dollar that comes out is added to taxable income for the year, taxed at the holder's marginal rate, and counted in the income tests for OAS and GIS. An RRSP has to be cashed, converted to a RRIF or used to buy an annuity in the year its holder turns 71, and a RRIF must pay out a yearly minimum starting the year after it is set up. We walked through the deadline and the minimum math in RRSP to RRIF explained.
TFSA. Withdrawals are tax-free, and the CRA confirms that neither TFSA income nor withdrawals affect federal income-tested benefits, OAS and GIS included. The account itself is covered in a TFSA is not a savings account.
Non-registered. Taking out the money originally invested isn't taxed. What is taxed is what the account earns. Interest has to be reported every year, even if it hasn't been paid out yet. Eligible Canadian dividends are reported at 138% of the amount received (as of 2026), and that larger figure is what counts in net income. Selling an investment that has grown realizes a capital gain, and part of that gain is taxable.
That last account is the one people tend to underestimate. A non-registered account produces taxable income whether anyone draws from it or not.
What the order actually changes
Lifetime tax. Canada taxes income in brackets, so a dollar taken in a low-income year can cost less than the same dollar stacked on top of pensions later. For 2026, the first federal bracket covers taxable income up to $58,523 at 14%, and the next runs to $117,045 at 20.5% (CRA, 2026 rates). Provincial brackets sit on top and differ by province.
The OAS recovery tax. Once net world income passes a threshold, 15% of the excess is paid back out of OAS. The threshold is $93,454 for 2025 income, which sets the deductions on payments from July 2026 to June 2027; for 2026 income it is $95,323, affecting July 2027 to June 2028. Thresholds are indexed and change every year. RRIF withdrawals count toward that test; TFSA withdrawals don't. We set out the clawback with real numbers in CPP and OAS explained.
What the estate inherits. At death, the full value of an RRSP or RRIF is generally income on the final return, unless it passes to a spouse or common-law partner under the rollover rules (more in estate taxes in Canada).
The question isn't which account is best. It's which dollar, taxed in which year.
Sequence one: non-registered first, RRSP or RRIF next, TFSA last
This is the conventional order. The logic is simple: spend from the account that is already being taxed every year, and leave the sheltered accounts to grow untouched for as long as possible. The TFSA goes last because it is the most flexible and the cleanest to pass on.
The trade-off shows up later. Left alone long enough, an RRSP doesn't stay quiet. It turns into forced income at exactly the age the government pensions are already paying, and a large RRIF minimum stacked on Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and OAS can push income into higher brackets or into recovery-tax range. Whatever is left at death is taxed in a single year unless a spouse rolls it over.
This order tends to suit people whose RRSP is modest next to their pensions, people with a large non-registered account that throws off taxable income regardless, and couples who expect the registered money to roll to a surviving spouse.
Sequence two: RRSP early, the "RRSP meltdown"
Here the RRSP is drawn down deliberately in the years between leaving work and the start of government pensions. CPP can start anywhere from 60 to 70, and OAS from 65 to as late as 70. Someone who retires at 60 and defers both can have several years of very low taxable income, with the lower brackets sitting empty. Filling them with RRSP withdrawals shrinks the balance, which means smaller forced minimums later, less exposure to the recovery tax, and less registered money taxed on the final return.
An illustration, with round numbers and illustrative tax rates. Picture someone who retires at 60 and draws $100,000 from her RRSP as $20,000 a year for five years, before CPP and OAS start. Suppose, for illustration only, those withdrawals face a 20% combined rate in those low-income years: $4,000 a year, or $20,000 over five years. Now suppose the same $100,000 stays put and comes out later, on top of pensions, at an illustrative 30%: $30,000. The $10,000 gap is the case for drawing early. It ignores growth and inflation, and real rates depend on province and total income; the point is the mechanism, not the number.
The trade-off: tax is paid sooner, and money withdrawn early stops growing tax-deferred, which narrows that gap. It also means living on savings while delaying pensions, which takes nerve when markets fall. This approach tends to suit people with a large RRSP relative to their other savings, early retirees with a gap before pensions begin, and single people, who have no spousal rollover to defer tax at death.
Sequence three: blended, to a chosen line each year
The blended approach takes RRSP or RRIF income each year up to a chosen point, often the top of a bracket or somewhere below the OAS threshold, and tops up spending from the TFSA or the non-registered account. The registered balance comes down steadily, without the spikes of either extreme.
The trade-off is attention. The line moves when brackets and thresholds are indexed, when CPP and OAS start, and when a spouse's income changes. It tends to suit people with meaningful money in all three account types, and couples who can coordinate two sets of income.
The levers that sit alongside the order
Pension income splitting. Couples can allocate up to 50% of eligible pension income to a spouse or common-law partner using Form T1032, and RRIF payments qualify once the transferring spouse is 65 or older at year-end. Ordinary RRSP withdrawals don't. That is one reason some people convert part of an RRSP to a RRIF at 65 rather than waiting for 71; how splitting fits with other couple strategies is in married money.
The pension income amount. A federal credit applies to up to $2,000 of eligible pension income. RRIF payments at 65 or older qualify; RRSP lump-sum withdrawals don't. Provincial versions exist, at different amounts.
RRIF minimums. Once an RRSP becomes a RRIF, the yearly minimum is mandatory, whatever the plan says. Any sequence has to be built around those floors, which are laid out in our RRIF piece.
When the RRIF pays more than you spend
A common pattern: when a RRIF minimum, or a deliberate meltdown withdrawal, is larger than what the household spends, the after-tax surplus goes into a TFSA. The tax on the RRIF withdrawal is still paid. What changes is where the money lives next: in an account where growth and future withdrawals are tax-free and invisible to the OAS and GIS income tests.
Room is the limit. The 2026 TFSA dollar limit is $7,000, unused room carries forward (from 2009, or from the year a person turned 18 if that came later), and amounts withdrawn are added back on January 1 of the next calendar year, not right away. Putting money back too soon is taxed at 1% a month on the excess. Many retirees have far more room than they realize; how it works is in our TFSA explainer, and how the two accounts compare is in RRSP vs TFSA.
What to check: questions to take to an adviser or planner
- What does projected taxable income look like each year from now to 71, and where does it land against the tax brackets and the OAS recovery threshold?
- What would drawing more from the RRSP before CPP and OAS start do to lifetime tax and to the balance left at 71?
- Does the plan use pension income splitting and the pension income amount from 65, and would converting part of the RRSP to a RRIF earlier help?
- Where does any RRIF income that isn't spent go, and is TFSA room being used?
- What happens to each account if one spouse dies first, and who is named as successor or beneficiary?
- How often is the withdrawal order revisited, and what would change it?
Where this leaves you
The tax rules price each choice. They don't make it. The order that fits depends on a few things only you know: what you actually spend in a year, and whether that changes as you age; your health, and how long you expect the money to need to last; whether leaving money to children or others matters to you, or whether spending it is the point; and, if you have a spouse, their age, income and savings, and which of you is likely to need the money longer.
This is general information, not personalized financial advice; your own situation may change the math.
Sources. Verified October 10, 2026. Service Canada, Old Age Security pension recovery tax (2025 and 2026 income thresholds, 15% repayment, monthly deduction periods). Service Canada, When to start your retirement pension (CPP) (start from 60 to 70). Service Canada, Old Age Security: When to start your pension (start from 65 to 70). CRA, Options for your own RRSPs (year you turn 71). CRA, Receiving income from a RRIF (minimum from the year after setup). CRA, Current year tax rates and income brackets (2026) (federal brackets). CRA, Line 12100: Interest and other investment income (annual reporting). CRA, Lines 12000 and 12010: Taxable amount of dividends (138% for eligible dividends). CRA, Line 12700: Taxable capital gains. CRA, Pension income splitting (50%, age 65 rule for RRIF payments, Form T1032). CRA, Line 31400: Pension income amount (up to $2,000; RRIF at 65 or older). CRA, What is a TFSA (no effect on OAS, GIS and other income-tested benefits). CRA, Before you contribute to a TFSA (2026 limit $7,000, room from 18, 1% a month on excess). CRA, Withdrawing from a TFSA (room restored January 1 of the next year). CRA, Death of a RRIF Annuitant (RC4178) and Death of an RRSP Annuitant (RC4177) (value included in income at death; spouse exceptions). Figures change; the date above is the one that applies.
Keep getting answers like this