Saving & investing

Leaving the bank's mutual funds: what moving to a self-directed account actually involves

A self-directed account holds the same RRSP, TFSA or retirement fund you have now, at a brokerage where every decision is yours. Here's how the move works, what it costs, and what it gives up.

Leaving the bank's mutual funds: what moving to a self-directed account actually involves

A self-directed account holds the same RRSP, TFSA or retirement fund you have now, at a brokerage where every decision is yours. Here's how the move works, what it costs, and what it gives up.

A self-directed account is not a new kind of account. It's the same RRSP, TFSA, Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) or non-registered account, held at an order-execution-only brokerage (often called a discount brokerage) where the holder makes every buy and sell decision. The main gains are lower ongoing fees and full control. The main losses are the adviser relationship, help with planning, and someone to talk you out of selling in a panic. The move itself can usually be done without triggering tax, as long as it happens as a direct transfer between institutions.

That last condition carries most of the risk.

What changes, and what doesn't

The Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO), which oversees investment dealers and mutual fund dealers, describes order-execution-only firms as letting investors trade on their own, without recommendations or suitability assessments. That's the trade in one line: the fee for someone else's judgment goes away, and so does the judgment.

  With a bank adviser Self-directed
Account types and tax rules RRSP, TFSA, RRIF, non-registered The same; the tax rules don't change
Choosing investments Recommended, checked for suitability The holder alone
Rebalancing Usually handled for you The holder, or a fund that does it internally
Ongoing fund costs Typically higher, with the adviser's pay built in Typically lower; trading costs vary
Tax slips Issued by the institution Issued by the institution

Why the ongoing cost differs, and what it pays for, is in our piece on the management expense ratio (MER).

How the move works: the new firm does the asking

The holder opens the matching account at the new brokerage and asks that firm to pull the assets over. For a TFSA, the CRA's page on requesting a TFSA transfer spells it out: ask the receiving financial institution to do a direct transfer, and the funds moved will not affect contribution room.

For an RRSP or RRIF, the paperwork commonly used is Form T2033, which the CRA describes as recording the direct transfer of property from an RRSP or RRIF to another RRSP or RRIF. The CRA notes it's used by the individual, the institution sending the money and the one receiving it. Done this way, the money never leaves the registered system, and the CRA states that amounts transferred directly into an RRSP do not affect the RRSP deduction limit.

CIRO's investor page on transferring accounts between firms says the process usually takes about 10 days, depending on what's in the account.

The one way to get it badly wrong

Don't withdraw from a TFSA or RRSP to "move" it yourself. A withdrawal and a transfer look similar on a statement; the tax rules treat them very differently.

Move the account, not the money.

In a TFSA, the CRA says money withdrawn and then deposited into a different TFSA "is considered a new contribution." Withdrawn amounts only come back as room the following year, so a holder who was already near the limit ends up over it. The excess is taxed at 1% a month. The CRA's own example: someone who moves $50,000 this way with no spare room pays $500 a month until the excess comes out. Our TFSA explainer covers the room rules in full.

In an RRSP, a withdrawal is taxable income. The institution withholds tax up front: 10% on amounts up to $5,000, 20% over $5,000 up to $15,000, and 30% over $15,000 (5%, 10% and 15% in Quebec, where provincial tax is withheld as well). That's a deposit on the bill, not the bill. The full amount lands on the year's return at the holder's marginal rate. And the room doesn't come back: the CRA's deduction limit calculation has no step that adds a withdrawal back in. As our RRSP vs TFSA piece puts it, an RRSP withdrawal is permanent.

In kind or in cash

An in-kind transfer moves the holdings as they are, without selling. CIRO notes this avoids potential tax consequences and keeps the money invested during the move. A cash transfer means selling first and moving the proceeds.

Here's the catch for bank clients. CIRO lists "securities sold exclusively by your old firm (proprietary products)" among the things that may not transfer. Bank-branded mutual funds fall into that group. The old firm moves what it can and asks what to do with the rest: generally, sell it and send the cash, or leave it where it is.

Inside an RRSP, TFSA or RRIF, selling to cash before a direct transfer doesn't create taxable income on its own. The cost is time out of the market while the cash is in transit, which can cut either way.

In a non-registered account, selling is a disposition. The CRA calculates a capital gain or loss as the proceeds minus the adjusted cost base (roughly, what was paid, including reinvested distributions) and selling costs. A fund held for many years may carry a large unrealized gain, and selling it to move it brings that gain onto this year's return. This is the part where an accountant earns their fee.

What it costs to leave

Transfer-out fees. CIRO says firms may charge one, and puts the range at $35 to $150 at most Canadian institutions. Fees vary, so the old firm's fee schedule is the place to look. Some receiving firms will cover transfer fees. Account closure fees are possible too.

Deferred sales charges (DSC). These are redemption fees for selling a fund within a set number of years of buying it. The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) banned new DSC sales as of June 1, 2022, and Ontario matched that date. But the ban doesn't erase old schedules. Units bought before June 1, 2022 are still subject to them until they expire, and the Ontario Securities Commission notes those schedules can last up to seven years. Selling a fund before its schedule ends still triggers the charge.

Trading costs. At the new firm, commissions vary. Some discount brokers offer commission-free trading, often with conditions. Account fees, currency conversion and the gap between buy and sell prices count too.

What the holder takes on

Rebalancing. When stocks rise and bonds don't, the mix drifts. Self-directed, pulling it back is the holder's job, or the job of a fund built to do it.

RRIF payments. The institution holding a RRIF still has to pay the minimum amount each year, starting the year after the RRIF is set up. What changes is that deciding which holdings to sell to raise that cash usually falls to the holder. The forced-withdrawal mechanics are in our RRSP to RRIF piece.

Taxes. Nothing about filing changes. The institution holding the account issues the slips, a T4RSP for an RRSP withdrawal for example, just as the bank did.

Behaviour. This one isn't on any fee schedule. In a bad year, nobody calls to talk you out of selling. Market value can fall, sometimes a lot, and past performance doesn't predict future results. How someone behaves in that stretch can matter more than what they paid in fees.

Protection. Brokerages that are CIRO members belong to the Canadian Investor Protection Fund (CIPF). If a member firm becomes insolvent, CIPF covers missing client property up to $1 million for general accounts (cash, margin, TFSAs and FHSAs combined) and a separate $1 million for registered retirement accounts (RRSPs, RRIFs and similar plans combined). It does not cover a drop in the value of investments for any reason.

One fund, one decision: all-in-one funds

A common approach among people who want a self-directed account without managing a dozen holdings is an asset allocation exchange-traded fund (ETF), sometimes called an all-in-one ETF. It's one fund holding a fixed mix of stocks and bonds that rebalances itself back to that mix. The holder's main decision is which mix fits their tolerance for ups and downs.

Two caveats. ETFs have an MER too, typically lower than a mutual fund's but never zero, and the same compounding math applies. And a balanced mix is still exposed to markets: its value can fall, and nothing says when a fall will reverse.

The middle ground

The choice isn't only "adviser" or "alone." Three in-between options are common.

Robo-advisers. The Ontario Securities Commission's overview describes online advisers that start with a questionnaire, build a model portfolio mostly of ETFs or low-cost mutual funds, and rebalance it, with a human adviser responsible for the decisions. The fee is usually a percentage of the portfolio, and trading or administrative fees may apply.

Fee-only planners. They're paid directly by the client, often by the hour or the project, rather than through fund commissions, and can help build a plan that a holder then carries out in a self-directed account.

Staying, at a lower cost. Some people keep their adviser and ask at the next review whether a lower-cost fund lineup is available.

What to check before moving

  • The funds you hold now, by name and fund code, and whether they're proprietary to the bank (if so, they'll likely be sold to cash).
  • Any DSC schedule still running on units bought before June 1, 2022, and when it ends.
  • The current firm's transfer-out and account closure fees, and whether the new firm reimburses them.
  • Which accounts are moving: RRSP, TFSA, RRIF, non-registered, or some of each.
  • For non-registered accounts, the adjusted cost base of each holding before anything is sold.
  • Whether the new platform supports every account type needed, including a RRIF and its scheduled payments.

Where this leaves you

The mechanics are the easy part: a direct transfer, started by the new firm, keeps the tax shelter intact. The harder questions are personal. What does the current fee actually buy, and is that something used? Who would rebalance, and who would make the call in a bad year? Would a hybrid, a robo-adviser, a fee-only planner or a cheaper lineup with the same adviser, cover what matters at a cost that feels fair? Only the account holder can answer those.

This is general information, not personalized financial advice; your own situation may change the math.


Sources. Verified October 10, 2026. CRA, Requesting a TFSA transfer (direct transfers, new-contribution rule, 1% monthly tax, $50,000 example). CRA, Saving for the future (TFSA room restored the following year; T4RSP slip). CRA, T2033 Direct Transfer (RRSP and RRIF direct transfers). CRA, Tax rates on withdrawals (withholding rates). CRA, How contributions affect your RRSP deduction limit (deduction limit calculation; direct transfers). CRA, Calculating and reporting your capital gains and losses (capital gain calculation). CRA, Registered Retirement Income Fund and Minimum amount from a RRIF (minimum payment timing; carrier pays). CIRO, home page (name, mandate, order-execution-only description) and Transferring Accounts Between Firms (timing, in kind vs cash, proprietary products, transfer-out fees). CIPF, About CIPF coverage (coverage limits and exclusions). CSA, Canadian securities regulators adopt ban on deferred sales charges (DSC ban date, existing schedules). Ontario Securities Commission, OSC to implement ban on deferred sales charge option (Ontario date). Ontario Securities Commission Investor Office, DSC and OEO trailer bans explained, Mutual fund fees, Commission-free trading and Robo-advisor basics and 4 Differences between ETFs and mutual funds (DSC schedules, trading costs, how robo-advisers work, ETF costs). Figures change; the date above is the one that applies.